About

About

Dr. Simoncic's practice emphasis is in sports medicine, arthroscopic surgery, and knee & shoulder replacement surgery. He has spent many years fine tuning the works of his practice. His reputation for quality orthopedic care is well documented in the community. He strives to provide the most conservative treatment plan possible for each problem. Only when all conservative treatment modalities have been exhausted does he recommend operative intervention. His office staff provides a patient friendly atmosphere. Patients are not subjected to long waiting times and the staff is geared to expedite treatment plans so that patients can get on with their lives as soon as possible.

Credentials

Credentials

  • Board certifications

    • Orthopaedic Surgery - American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery

  • Academic titles

    • Assistant Professor, Donald and Barbara Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra/Northwell

  • Medical school

    • SUNY Health Science Center at Brooklyn

  • Residencies

    • Lenox Hill Hospital

  • Internships

    • Lenox Hill Hospital

  • Fellowships

    • NYU Langone-Hospital for Joint Diseases

  • Affiliations

Locations & insurance

Locations & insurance

833 Northern Boulevard, Suite 220Great Neck, NY 11021

Insurance information

Don't be surprised

Learn how you can avoid unanticipated medical bills

Learn more about medical bills

Patient ratings & comments

Patient ratings & comments

Unlike websites where anyone can post doctor reviews, only actual patients can provide information by completing the survey sent to them by Press Ganey. Learn more.

4.7 out of 5 4.7 out of 5 rating
| 223.0 patient ratings & 54 patient comments

Friendliness/courtesy of the care provider

4.8 out of 5 4.8 out of 5 rating

Explanations the care provider gave you about your problem or condition

4.7 out of 5 4.7 out of 5 rating

Concern the care provider showed for your questions or worries

4.7 out of 5 4.7 out of 5 rating

Care provider's efforts to include you in decisions about your treatment

4.7 out of 5 4.7 out of 5 rating

Information the care provider gave you about medications(if any)

4.7 out of 5 4.7 out of 5 rating

Instructions the care provider gave you about follow up care (if any)

4.7 out of 5 4.7 out of 5 rating

Degrees to which care provider talked with you using words you could understand

4.8 out of 5 4.8 out of 5 rating

Amount of time the care provider spent with you

4.6 out of 5 4.6 out of 5 rating

Your confidence in this care provider

4.7 out of 5 4.7 out of 5 rating

Likelihood of your recommending this care provider to others

4.7 out of 5 4.7 out of 5 rating

Most recent comments

Patient comments are gathered from the Press Ganey Pateint Satisfaction Survey. Comments are displayed in their entirety and are anonymous for patient privacy.

09/04/2018
"Dr. Simoncic is a very caring physician & I would recommend him to family & friends. He explained everything to me in a manner I understood."
07/25/2018
"dr simoncic is a very caring and understanding doctor."
07/23/2018
"Dr. Simoncic is very thorough, explains in detail all that needs to be done & shows genuine care & concern no matter what your fears or questions may be; besides the fact that he is a fantastic surgeon.....I am so grateful to him for doing my complete reverse right shoulder replacement & to Margaret for squeezing me in ASAP because I was in agonizing pain when I fell & broke it. I've had plenty of experience with this office, as I had bilateral knee replacements the year before. This office has high volume of patients & everything always runs smoothly. I am forever grateful to Dr. Simoncic & Dr. Krauss for all their expertise."
07/10/2018
"LOVE THE DOCTOR, THE NURSES AND THE RECEPTIONISTS. EVERYONE IS VERY COURTEOUS AND KIND"
06/22/2018
"Excellent surgeon."
06/16/2018
"Dr. Jay Simonsic Ian absolutely the BEST doctor!!!"
05/21/2018
"the Drs at this office treat me very well and I tell anyone about them who need this kind of dr"
05/17/2018
"Dr. Simoncic operated on my right elbows about 5 years ago. He did a great job and I am very happy he is able to help me this time again."
05/17/2018
"Dr. Simoncic is fantastic. He is friendly and knowledgeable and speaks to you in a way you can understand. He even drew the ligament I tore for me, all while explaining the process of repairing it. No other doctors have taken the time in the past to explain things the way he did."
04/27/2018
"All very good. "
04/24/2018
"My regular dr. & Dr. D. But since he has been away - I have been seeing Dr. Simoncic - and he has been very good to me also."
04/23/2018
"Dr. Jay Simoncic is the "Best Doctor ever". The most professional courteous, competent knowledgeable. He makes you feel so comfortable. I have full confidence in him."
04/23/2018
"dr. Simoncic has always been terrific. he is thorough in reviewing the situation and explaining what follow up is needed."
03/19/2018
"I think he just seemed rushed that day which made me feel only fair about the whole experience with the healthcare provider"
01/03/2018
"The whole staff is wonderful - Dr. Jay S. Simoncic distinguish himself by being exceptionally extraordinary care provider. So competent, knowledgeable, caring, reassuring - all his patient must have full confidence on him -"
12/30/2017
"Dr. Simoncic showed he desired to give me the best care he possibly could. He discussed my case in a realistic manner discussing possible outcomes for my case. I felt confident Dr. Simoncic was going to give me the best care I could receive."
12/26/2017
"Excellent care once I got into exam room"
12/18/2017
"Dr. Simoncic apologized for the delay, however, he is fantastic. he always explains all procedures thoroughly, is extremely informative, caring & professional."
10/30/2017
"Dr Simoncic is wonderful ! He took the time to explain everything and all my options for my condition."
10/20/2017
"Doctor is wonderful. Did two knee replacements recently broken right wrist. Always concerned and considerate of how I'm doing."
10/16/2017
"Pleasant physician."
10/05/2017
"Always recommend Dr. Jay."
09/25/2017
"I have sent this dr. many friends & they were all happy with him."
08/29/2017
"excellent in every aspect!"
07/31/2017
"Dr Simoncics level of expertise is proven. However he does sift through the visit quickly.Patients should have questions or concerns dprepared prior to visit."
07/31/2017
"Dr. Simoncic was informative & clear in explanations & details."
07/19/2017
"Good experience. "
05/17/2017
"Good experience."
03/27/2017
"my dr(Simonic) was in a big hurry with me and i felt i did not receive the quality f care i should have"
03/11/2017
"Great personality!"
01/25/2017
"Dr. Simoncic is a very down to earth and easy to talk to. I have recommend him to others."
01/16/2017
"great doctor and and very kind person"
11/14/2016
"I've recommended a friend and they're extremely happy and satisfied with the surgeon and the office staff. it's a pleasure to recommend this to anyone because of the curtesy and care and concern given at each phase of the visit!"
11/12/2016
"very good"
10/07/2016
"Good."
10/05/2016
"All good."
09/13/2016
"I have total confidence with Dr. J. Simoncic and his office. Would absolutely recommend him to everyone."
09/07/2016
"Good experiences in past."
09/06/2016
"Dr. Simoncic is competant and professional. he is knowledgeable and courteous. His ability in his specialty makes him an MD who inspires confidence.the other issues are secondary. he is worth waiting for, and I value his professional expertise and his recommendations!"
08/30/2016
"Medication was not discussed. I recommended the provider to a dear friend."
08/07/2016
"Good."
07/08/2016
"The doctor was abrupt and rude. Lack of concern to my needs."
06/21/2016
"always a good experience."
04/05/2016
"My pre-surgical, surgical & post-surgical periods have all gone without any problems."
11/02/2015
"Doctor help me and my son a lot. We have a very good experience with Doctor Simoncic ."
09/30/2015
"All positive!"
09/23/2015
"I have always received courtesy transport from Dr. Simoncic & the staff and have always had full confidence in my care!"
08/06/2015
"All good."
06/10/2015
"Well-defined and very good experience."
04/27/2015
"Very satisfied with care received by Dr. Simoncic and staff."
03/06/2015
"Very good experience."
06/27/2014
"I've used him for many years. I've recommended him."
06/19/2014
"Everyone was pleasant and caring."
04/22/2014
"Dr. Simoncic is great."